(defun member-if-over-1 (x) (cond ((endp x) nil) ((< 1 (car x)) x) (t (member-if-over-1 (cdr x))))) (defun sum (x) (if (endp x) 0 (+ (car x) (sum (cdr x))))) (defthm pigeonhole (implies (< (len x) (sum x)) (member-if-over-1 x))) (defun list-count (e x) (cond ((endp x) 0) ((equal e (car x)) (1+ (list-count e (cdr x)))) (t (list-count e (cdr x))))) (defthm member-remove (implies (not (equal x y)) (iff (member x (remove y z)) (member x z)))) (defthm no-duplicatesp-remove (implies (no-duplicatesp x) (no-duplicatesp (remove e x)))) (defun map-list-count (x s) (if (endp s) nil (cons (list-count (car s) x) (map-list-count (remove (car s) x) (cdr s))))) (defthm len-map-list-count (equal (len (map-list-count x s)) (len s))) (defthm len-remove (equal (len (remove e x)) (- (len x) (list-count e x)))) (defthm not-subsetp-remove (implies (not (subsetp (remove e x) y)) (not (subsetp x (cons e y))))) (defthm sum-map-list-count (implies (and (no-duplicatesp s) (subsetp x s)) (equal (sum (map-list-count x s)) (len x))) :hints (("Goal" :induct (map-list-count x s)))) (defthm not-no-duplicatesp-list-count (implies (< 1 (list-count e x)) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :rule-classes ((:rewrite :match-free :all))) (defthm not-no-duplicatesp-remove (implies (not (no-duplicatesp (remove e x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :rule-classes ((:rewrite :match-free :all))) (defthm member-if-over-1-map-list-count-is-duplicated (implies (and (no-duplicatesp s) (subsetp x s) (member-if-over-1 (map-list-count x s))) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :hints (("Goal" :induct (map-list-count x s))) :rule-classes ((:rewrite :match-free :all))) (defthm pigeonhole-for-list (implies (and (no-duplicatesp s) (subsetp x s) (< (len s) (len x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :rule-classes ((:rewrite :match-free :all))) (in-theory (disable pigeonhole-for-list)) (defthm blood-types-are-duplicates (implies (and (subsetp x '(A B O AB)) (<= 5 (len x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :hints (("Goal" :use (:instance pigeonhole-for-list (s '(A B O AB)) (x x))))) (defthm birth-months-are-duplicates (let ((birth-months '(1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12))) (implies (and (subsetp x birth-months) (<= 13 (len x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x)))) :hints (("Goal" :use (:instance pigeonhole-for-list (s '(1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12)) (x x))))) (defun nats-below (n) (if (zp n) nil (cons (- n 1) (nats-below (- n 1))))) (defthm len-nats-below (implies (natp n) (equal (len (nats-below n)) n))) (defun all-under-p (x n) (if (endp x) t (and (< (car x) n) (all-under-p (cdr x) n)))) (defthm all-under-p-lemma (implies (and (posp n) (all-under-p x (+ -1 n))) (all-under-p x n))) (defthm all-under-p-nats-below (all-under-p (nats-below n) n)) (defthm all-under-p-not-member (implies (all-under-p x n) (not (member n x)))) (defthm not-member-nats-below (not (member n (nats-below n)))) (defthm no-duplicatesp-nats-below (no-duplicatesp (nats-below n))) (defthm duplicates-nats (implies (and (integerp n) (<= 0 n) (subsetp x (nats-below n)) (< n m) (<= m (len x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x))) :rule-classes ((:rewrite :match-free :all)) :hints (("Goal" :use (:instance pigeonhole-for-list (s (nats-below n)) (x x))))) (in-theory (disable duplicates-nats)) (defthm numbers-of-hairs-are-duplicates-in-gunma (let ((max-number-of-hairs 250000) (gunma-population 2000000)) (implies (and (subsetp x (nats-below max-number-of-hairs)) (= gunma-population (len x))) (not (no-duplicatesp x)))) :hints (("Goal" :use (:instance duplicates-nats (n 250000) (m 2000000) (x x)))))